San Diego County Performance Update 2020

On a national basis, 2019 was marked by a modest slowdown for the hotel industry. This decline has been primarily driven by a decrease in business investment, business confidence, trade fears and the “year before an election year” mindset, where many expect a slight uptick in 2020, even after 10 straight years of growth. “A slide in business travel is expected to continue through the start of 2020 before beginning a soft recovery in Q3. This slowdown should see unemployment tick upwards, but elevated personal savings, low interest rates, moderate inflation, and healthy consumer confidence levels should prevent a steep decline in consumer spending,” according to Tourism Economics. GDP growth is expected to continue in the 2.3 percent range this year according to Bernard Baumohl of the Economic Outlook Group.

Based on that not so robust economy, lodging industry fundamentals have been decelerating as we enter the new decade of the ‘20s. STR projects that all segments are likely to report occupancy decreases in 2020, led by upscale hotels at -0.9 percent. According to STR, luxury will post the biggest gains at 1.2 percent in ADR and 0.9 percent in RevPAR. Looking ahead to 2021, independent hotels are projected to have flat occupancy growth and 1 percent RevPAR growth, while all other segments are expected to report declines in occupancy. Again, luxury in 2021 is projected to show 1.3 percent ADR growth.

Hoteliers can still optimize the performance of their assets, by focusing on creating demand. It is paramount to focus on marketing, sales and revenue strategies that create new demand – sales efforts should be proactive, revenue management requires micro-management of brand revenue managers, distribution strategies and tactics should be driven by a return-on-investment analysis and marketing must be digital and aggressively in pursuit of everything from social channels to remarketing.

Considering that revenues will be difficult to grow in a slow-growth environment, proactive labor cost management strategies to enhance recruitment, training and retention efforts will help reduce turnover and increase social media and guest satisfaction scores. Slower RevPAR growth creates an opportunity to finalize capital projects with less disruption and/or displacement. Robotics can be utilized for delivery to rooms and vacuuming, digital key reduces the need for that extra desk staff and all of these free up the need for managers to perform tasks. A positive work culture will become even more important and the cost of replacing team members should keep us honest about taking care of great employees.

According to Kalibri Labs, average length of stay continues to compress, making optimal channel mix more important than ever. Growth in hotel demand exceeded supply growth in 2019 as evidenced by increases in both Guest Paid RevPAR and Occupancy. Total US loyalty contribution increased +7.6 percent year-over-year to 56.0 percent of total bookings in 2019. When the “book direct” campaigns began in 2016, total yearend US loyalty contribution was 47.9 percent.

Google Trips could have a significant impact on metasearch and marketing overall, so hotels need to pay attention and understand the functionality, how OTAs are participating and what the impact will be on hotels to determine their strategy, including the potential need to shift more of their marketing dollars to Google. Allocations of these dollars should be based on returns that we’re seeing and we should be flexible to change as the performance of different marketing vehicles changes. What works today might not work tomorrow but one thing that will not change is the importance of mobile and the number of hours our potential guests spend on digital media.

 

San Diego

San Diego’s economy is strong, with unemployment dropping to 2.8 percent at the end of 2019, well ahead of the US at 3.4 percent. In the hotel sector, San Diego’s 2019 supply growth outpaced demand, dropping occupancy levels by 2.4 percent to 76.7 percent. Revenue per available room (RevPAR) contracted 2.1 percent in 2019 to $127.95 after a slight gain in the first half of the year, and average daily room rate (ADR) grew by only 0.3 percent for the year, increasing to $166.78 according to STR.

To provide some perspective, San Diego’s visitor industry employs directly and indirectly 194,000 San Diegans. Visitors spend nearly $11.5 billion annually. San Diego hosts nearly 35.8 million visitors each year, and is a top U.S. travel destination. The industry generates $855 million annually in state and local transient occupancy, sales, and property taxes. 2019 showed mixed results, as visitors to the city declined while expenditures within the destination increased.

San Diego’s current forecast expects prolonged stable visitation growth from 2020 to 2024 and should produce average growth between 1.9 percent and 2.2 percent each year. Both day and overnight visitation are expected to experience moderate gains in 2020, with day visitors (2.6 percent) outpacing overnight (1.9 percent). Room supply growth is expected to outpace demand in 2020 leading to a slight downward trend in occupancy that should stabilize at 76.9 percent. ADR is expected to accelerate to 1.8 percent in 2020 and 2.1 percent in 2021. With the slide in occupancy, RevPAR is expected to show an increase of 1.7 and 2.3 percent in 2020 and 2021, respectively, led primarily by the increases in ADR.

Source: Tourism Economics/STR/SDTA

Year	Occupancy	ADR	RevPAR
2010	66%	$122	$81
2011	69%	$126	$87
2012	71%	$132	$93
2013	72%	$136	$97
2014	75%	$142	$106
2015	76%	$151	$115
2016	77%	$155	$119
2017	77%	$160	$123
2018	78%	$165	$128
2019	77%	$167	$129
2020 (forecast)	77%	$170	$131

 

Following is a review of 2019 and a forecast for 2020. While 2019 and 2020 will add new hotel supply beyond that of 2018, San Diego will remain a strong market for the foreseeable future and should be able to hold the overall 77 percent occupancy for the next few years.

San Diego County

In 2019, occupancy in San Diego County decreased 2.4 percent to 76.7 percent and average rate grew 0.3 percent to $166.78. Revenue per available room (RevPAR) moved down 2.1 percent to $127.95. New hotels that were added in 2019 included 1,656 rooms with a total impact of 940 rooms and hotels currently under construction in 2020 total 1,440 rooms with a projected impact of 916 rooms.

Note: Impact is determined by the opening date; i.e. a hotel that opens July 1 impacts half of a year.

Hotels Opened in 2019	Rooms	Impact in 2019
TownePlace Suites San Diego Central	106	97
Hampton Inn and Suites by Hilton – Liberty Station	181	151
Sycuan Casino Resort Hotel	302	252
Marriott SpringHill Suites	107	71
The Guild Hotel	162	95
Ayres Hotel – Millenia Chula Vista	135	68
TownePlace Suites Liberty Station	222	93
Carte Hotel & Suites Downtown San Diego	246	82
Hampton Inn Chula Vista Eastlake	104	17
Homewood Suites Chula Vista Eastlake	92	15
TOTAL	1,656	940

 

Hotels Opening in 2020	Rooms	Impact in 2020
Legacy International Center	127	127
Ayres Hotel Vista	100	83
Hampton Inn El Cajon	96	80
Hampton Inn & Suites Imperial Beach	100	67
Home2 Suites – Carlsbad/Palomar Airport	146	97
Town and Country San Diego – Remodel	675	394
SpringHill Suites Carlsbad San Diego	104	61
The Monsaraz, A Tapestry by Hilton Collection Hotel	92	8
TOTAL	1,440	916

 

In 2019, the 1.5 percent supply increase and 1 percent drop in demand caused a 2.4 percent occupancy decline, largely due to a weak Q4 convention calendar. In 2020, we expect a 1.6 percent increase in demand to keep pace with new supply. Demand in the market continues to be balanced. San Diego remains a top-tier convention destination, with the San Diego Convention Center. Other demand generators, such as Balboa Park, Sea World, the San Diego Zoo, Legoland, the Gaslamp District, Petco Park, and world-class beaches, have helped drive tourism to record levels in the past few years. The local economy continues to expand, with tech startups, increases in military spending, residential development, and record-high levels of visitation. Perhaps one of the biggest impacts to long-term San Diego growth in tourism will be the vote next month on the convention center. Measure C will determine if the Convention Center will expand, putting San Diego in competition for large city-wide conventions or if it will stay a small convention market that cannot handle simultaneous events.

The outlook for the San Diego market is positive due to anticipated high-quality hotels entering the market, the market’s high barriers to entry, the strong base of group and government demand, and favorable economic conditions throughout Southern California.

 

Downtown

Downtown San Diego hit an occupancy of 80.9 percent, with an average rate of $207.27. A RevPAR decline of 2 percent brought 2019 RevPAR to $167.69. Downtown is driven largely by group business, convention center demand, some corporate and fairly strong leisure demand due to the always improving downtown lifestyle and environment. The convention center alone is expected to contribute significant room nights in the Downtown market (and to other submarkets through compression) from over 130 events. Little Italy, the Gaslamp Quarter and the waterfront provide very strong demand year around.

2020 will bring additional hotel construction as well as strong convention center demand due to strong cyclical bookings by the San Diego Tourism Authority. Two new hotels opened Downtown in 2019: The Guild Hotel that opened in June and the Carte Hotel & Suites Downtown San Diego that opened in September. New supply will be up 3.55 percent while demand will increase by at least three percent due to the convention calendar. We anticipate that Airbnb will have a significant impact on average rates during peak periods, however, the overall annualized impact will be minimal in 2020. The improved convention calendar should keep occupancy levels solid this year.

 

Point Loma Peninsula

This submarket finished 2019 with occupancy rates of 76.7 percent, down an astounding 4.7 percent from 2018, based largely on new supply growth. Average rates grew to $142.50, up 0.8 percent and RevPAR was $109.31, down by 4 percent. Hotels here are generally close to the airport and of all product types from full-service to limited-service, waterfront to near downtown transient accommodations.

Perhaps the single most interesting development in this sub-market has been the growth of Liberty Station. This combination arts and foodie district has stimulated significant lodging supply and demand. Point Loma had 403 rooms added in 2019 from the TownePlace Suites Liberty Station and Hampton Inn and Suites by Hilton – Liberty Station. The Monsaraz, A Tapestry Collection Hotel is expected to open in Q4 of 2020. This market has been extremely steady and will drop occupancy levels for a year or two before rebounding back toward 80 percent.

 

Mission Valley

The Mission Valley submarket saw occupancy levels of 78.3 percent in 2019, down 3.9 percent from 2018. Average rates were $126.71, down 1.3 percent from 2018 and RevPAR was $99.17, down by 5.1 percent. The Mission Valley submarket has seen a fundamental shift away from the older Hotel Circle hotels of the 1970s and 1980s to branded, strong limited-service products and mostly renovated full-service hotels. Demand is driven largely by groups and leisure but has been increasingly gathering corporate business. Mission Valley hotels opened in 2019 included TownePlace Suites San Diego Central with 106 rooms.

In 2020, the Legacy International Center will add 127 rooms to Mission Valley in Q1. This non-traditional lodging facility should have minimal impact on traditional lodging supply and demand dynamics. The multi-million-dollar renovation of the Town and Country Hotel, however, will impact this market.

 

La Jolla

The La Jolla market had occupancy levels of 75.7 percent, a decrease of 1.9 percent from 2018. Average rates grew almost 2 percent to $257.07 with RevPAR showing no change from 2018 at $194.54. This submarket has very strong leisure business, some group business and light corporate business. It includes all of the hotel product in or around the Village of La Jolla. La Jolla is a favorite of higher end leisure travelers. With no new supply, the pattern of growth for this normally very strong submarket will continue albeit in a somewhat muted way.

 

Mission Bay

Mission Bay hit occupancy levels of 77.4 percent, down 4.6 percent over 2018. Average rates were $193.55, down by 1.3 percent and RevPAR was $149.90, down 3.4 percent year over year. Mission Bay is a group market with mostly older, waterfront hotels that have been substantially renovated. In most cases, these are independent hotels that benefit from a strong amenity package and waterfront locations. Mission Bay has not added new hotels and will continue to perform well.

Year over year change in supply in Mission Bay increased by 0.3 percent, while demand declined by 4.4 percent. We expect an uptick in demand in this normally very strong market. No new hotels are opening in Mission Bay, but the $35 million-dollar rebranding of Paradise Point to become Margaritaville will change the dynamics of this market segment.

 

Northwest

In 2019 San Diego County Northwest (Del Mar/Oceanside) saw a decrease in occupancy to 71.5 percent, down 3.3 percent from 2018 with average rates up 0.3 percent to $166.82. RevPAR saw a decline of 3.3 percent, moving down to $122.43. Led by a very solid Carlsbad market, this area benefits from strong corporate and leisure demand but new supply over the past couple of years has reduced Carlsbad occupancy levels.

Oceanside has finally blossomed into a force with solid leisure demand and amenities that include a new Oceanside High School Performing Arts Center, 1,000 slip harbor, airport, San Luis Rey Mission and Mira Costa College. New full-service lodging will also increase demand going forward. The area has seen massive increases in supply over the past few years and has absorbed this supply well as Carlsbad continues to have a deep reservoir of industrial and corporate demand generators including ViaSat and ThermoFisher Scientific. LEGOLAND California, Carlsbad Premium Outlets and Carlsbad’s downtown Village provide strong leisure demand.  Having said that, the supply of limited-service hotels needs to slow as demand cannot continue to keep the pace of recent supply growth. The SpringHill Suites Carlsbad San Diego is expected to add 104 rooms in June of 2020.

 

North Inland

This submarket hit occupancy of 74.1 percent, down 2.1 percent from 2018. Average rates were $144.77, up 4 percent year over year. RevPAR was $107.26, up 1.8 percent from 2018. This area includes Kearny Mesa, Rancho Bernardo and Miramar and has recently become better equipped to handle leisure business with the combination of the San Diego Zoo Safari Park, golf courses, wineries, breweries and other attractions. It includes residential areas, commercial and light industrial districts. Military demand stems from the Marine Corps Air Station in Miramar.

The Marriott SpringHill Suites added 107 rooms to the market supply in May of 2019.

 

Northeast

In 2019 San Diego County Northeast (Escondido, San Marcos, and Vista) saw occupancy levels increase to 71.2 percent,

up 0.6 percent with rates up to $116.57, an increase of 1.4 percent, and RevPAR up 1.9 percent to $84.74. Escondido has finally created a cross-section of demand generators in the corporate and leisure markets, San Marcos has benefited from very strong growth in the health care and education sector, and Vista is located proximate to both Carlsbad and San Marcos with its own industrial park demand.

The SR-78 corridor, coupled with the growth of California State University San Marcos, Palomar Community College, Pima Medical Institute and other health care facilities and population growth make this an area that is desirable. Springhill Suites opened in Escondido in the spring of 2019 and the Ayres Hotel Vista will add 100 new rooms to the market in March 2020.

 

North Coastal

This group of hotels finished 2019 at 81.1 percent, a slight decrease of 0.3 percent from 2018 and had an average rate of $186.58, with no change year over year. RevPAR showed a slight decrease of 0.2 percent from 2018 at $151.25. This submarket includes Sorrento Valley, Carmel Valley and UTC and continues to be an 80 percent plus market.

Half the hotels are full-service and the other half are limited-service and they range from the Fairmont Grand Del Mar on the high end to economy properties in Sorrento Mesa. The market has strong group, leisure and corporate demand from multiple industrial parks, biotechnology, life science and medical equipment companies as well as the communication technology sector. Its proximity to Del Mar expands the reach of hotels here by providing very strong leisure demand and the renovation of UTC will be a major plus later in 2020.

 

By Robert Rauch and Sarah Andersen